Why, despite the incredible safety record of modern aviation, do accidents still occur? Asking the question is easy and repetitive. It’s harder to come up with repeatable actionable steps to take.
For instance, there is much behind the scenes in the Boeing 737 MAX debacle. Boeing’s problems have been well explored but the whitewash of the second crash investigation shows another layer of safety that was completely overlooked. But each incident is more than a headline or a statistical entry. It is paid for in lives, reputational and huge financial expense. This is just as true for general aviation and corporate operators as it is for the airlines.
Bruce Landsberg’s Learning From Icarus provides a roadmap to stop treating safety as a fixed standard and start treating it as a moving target, requiring ongoing, vigilance, training, and humility. As he states, the soft underbelly of human psychology is messy but essential to understand and manage if you want to improve the record. Familiarity breeds contempt.
Many crashes begin on the ground, long before the wheels leave the runway. Critical decision-making, planning, or mindset determines how a flight will unfold. This means moving beyond rote memorization and checklist compliance to embrace scenario-based training that reflects real-world complexity. Sometimes, the crash occurs from a spur-of-the-moment lapse and here is where procedure and practice pay off.
Improved and expanded simulation is a key aspect, especially in light aircraft. As Landsberg notes, all aircraft make terrible classrooms. The airlines and business jet operators adapted to simulators very quickly. Simulators and procedures training, when used effectively, offer safer, more cost-effective opportunities to practice routine, difficult or emergency scenarios. Pilots can fail, repeat, and learn without risk. Unfortunately, many flight schools and CFIs prioritize flight hours over mental readiness, missing the opportunity to develop muscle memory and deep judgment skills in controlled environments. But at some point, after the basics are absorbed, we have to fly and the book points out many pitfalls.
Fatigue is another silent killer. In commercial aviation, crew rest rules aim to protect pilots from exhaustion. But fatigue creeps in through long commutes, back-to-back flights, or irregular schedules which the industry continually demands due to economics. For instance, the Colgan Air 3407 disaster, which is discussed in Learning From Icarus, demonstrated how both pilots were exhausted, and the captain was badly under skilled, yet politics resulted in the “1,500 hour rule.
Third, we must normalize honest error reporting without fear of punishment. Programs like NASA’s ASRS and FAA’s ASAP and ATSAP allow pilots and controllers to report mistakes anonymously so others can learn from them. But many still hesitate. They fear retribution or shame. As long as mistakes are hidden, others will repeat them. Therefore, Landsberg argues that transparency is critical, especially when lives are at stake.
Continue to invest in technology, but not blindly. Tools like ADS-B, terrain avoidance systems, and digital weather updates have significantly improved situational awareness. While they are not foolproof and can cause errors, the magic often does a much better job of informing the pilot. But pilots must understand both what the systems do and what they don’t, to improve routine operation and respond to the rare sudden malfunction.
The line between over-confidence and being fearful is a thin one. Understand the limitations of the gear, our own abilities, and stamina. When ignorance and arrogance are combined, as Landsberg cautions, “the results are guaranteed to be spectacular.” The antidote is continuous learning, thoughtful reflection, and respect for the risks.
Risk cannot be completely eliminated from aviation, or any other mode of transport. Instead, it is about mitigating it through better decisions, smarter systems, and a culture that values vigilance over bravado. Learning From Icarus reminds us, that the wisdom is there; we just have to use it wisely. Sounds easy. It’s not.
Order your copy on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/1968296557/.
